Quality of reporting statistics in two Indian pharmacology journals

ABSTRACT

Objective: To evaluate the reporting of the statistical methods in articles published in two Indian pharmacology journals. Materials and Methods: All original articles published since 2002 were downloaded from the journals’ (Indian Journal of Pharmacology (IJP) and Indian Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology (IJPP)) website. These articles were evaluated on the basis of appropriateness of descriptive statistics and inferential statistics. Descriptive statistics was evaluated on the basis of reporting of method of description and central tendencies. Inferential statistics was evaluated on the basis of fulfi lling of assumption of statistical methods and appropriateness of statistical tests. Values are described as frequencies, percentage, and 95% confi dence interval (CI) around the percentages. Results: Inappropriate descriptive statistics was observed in 150 (78.1%, 95% CI 71.7–83.3%) articles. Most common reason for this inappropriate descriptive statistics was use of mean ± SEM at the place of “mean (SD)” or “mean ± SD.” Most common statistical method used was one-way ANOVA (58.4%). Information regarding checking of assumption of statistical test was mentioned in only two articles. Inappropriate statistical test was observed in 61 (31.7%, 95% CI 25.6–38.6%) articles. Most common reason for inappropriate statistical test was the use of two group test for three or more groups. Conclusion: Articles published in two Indian pharmacology journals are not devoid of statistical errors.

KEYWORDS

• Inappropriate statistics
• Indian Journals
• Pharmacology

Showing references and in-text citations exactly as published.

• DOI10.4103/0976-500X.81897Copy

RELATED ARTICLES

Matched on section and article type within this issue of J Pharmacol. Pharmacother..

• Article · VOLUME 2, ISSUE 2Adverse drug reaction profile of oseltamivir in childrenPrashant S. Dalvi, Anil Singh, Hiren R. Trivedi, Suresh D. Mistry, Bhadresh R. Vyas · pp. 100–103Research PaperSame type: Article
• Article · VOLUME 2, ISSUE 2Use of topical brimonidine to prevent intraocular pressure elevations following Nd: YAG-laser posterior capsulotomyDeepika Singhal, Roopali Desai, Sejal Desai, Manisha Shastri, Deepak Saxena · pp. 104–106Research PaperSame type: Article
• Article · VOLUME 2, ISSUE 2Hypolipidemic and weight reducing activity of the ethanolic extract of Tamarindus indica fruit pulp in cafeteria diet- and sulpiride-induced obese ratsVaneeta Jindal, Dinesh Dhingra, Sunil Sharma, Milind Parle, Rajinder Kumar Harna · pp. 80–84Research PaperSame type: Article
• Article · VOLUME 2, ISSUE 2Effect of ormeloxifene, a nonsteroidal once-a-week oral contraceptive, on systemic hemodynamics in adult female ratsHiralal Bhalla, Kamlesh Kumar Pant, Madhu Dikshit, William R. Surin, Man Mohan Singh · pp. 90–94Research PaperSame type: Article